海角社区

海角社区, Investments, & Insurance for Individuals Build your knowledge Pay off debt with retirement savings? 3 reasons to reconsider

Pay off debt with retirement savings? 3 reasons to reconsider

Using retirement savings to pay off debt can have an impact on your financial foundation now and in the future.

 Young woman working on budget and retirement plans on computer
4 min read |

The average full-time employed American works about 8.5 hours a day, reads about 12 books a year, spends close to seven hours on screens per day 鈥攁nd has debt. In fact, if you鈥檙e like most Americans, you have more than $104,000 that you owe on credit cards, mortgages, student loans, and more.

On the flip side, though, if you鈥檝e started saving for retirement, you may have made good progress. For example, the average working household ages 45鈥54 with a 401(k)/individual retirement account (IRA) has accumulated a savings of about $115,000.

If you鈥檙e trying to get out of debt, those retirement savings are tempting. 鈥淲e sometimes think,鈥'I have these retirement savings at my disposal,鈥欌 says Stanley Poorman, financial professional with Principal. 鈥淏ut that鈥檚 there for retirement. There are other tools to use.鈥

In fact, raiding your retirement savings to pay off debt may equal more short- and long-term costs than you realize. Here are some tradeoffs to consider.

You鈥檒l pay penalties and taxes for using retirement savings to pay off debt.

Every retirement account鈥攁 traditional IRA, Roth IRA, and 401(k)鈥攈as age distribution limits. That means some combination of penalties and taxes may hit you for early withdrawals.

Account type Early withdrawal costs
IRA You鈥檒l get dinged with a 10% penalty on the full amount you withdraw, plus taxes at your current income tax bracket. (Some鈥痚xceptions to the penalty charge, like using funds for a first-time homeowner down payment, apply.)
Roth IRA It鈥檚 important to distinguish between contributions and earnings for a Roth IRA. You can withdraw the former at any time and any age, tax- and penalty-free (remember, you鈥檝e already paid taxes on Roth IRA contributions). If you withdraw earnings at any time, you must pay taxes on them. If you make a withdrawal before the account is five years old, you鈥檒l pay a 10% penalty and taxes.
401(k) You鈥檒l pay a 10% penalty on the withdrawal plus taxes at your current rate.

Let鈥檚 say that you have $20,000 in credit card debt. What are the true costs (and how much will you really see) if you withdraw from a 401(k) to pay it off?

Withdrawal Subtract your early withdrawal penalty Subtract your estimated income tax The withdrawal amount
$20,000 $2,000 $4,000 $14,000鈥攍eaving you with $6,000 in your original debt

You may lose out on potential earnings if you use retirement savings to pay off debt.

If you withdraw that $20,000 to pay off debt, you鈥檙e also eliminating the opportunity to grow those funds over the long-term鈥攐therwise known as compounding interest.

$20,000 retirement balance multiplied by 20 years of growth multiplied by 6% estimated growth rate equals $64,143 ending balance

鈥淲eigh all the impacts,鈥 Poorman says. 鈥淪ome impacts you can recover from, and some you may not. Can you really ramp up your retirement savings rate to recover? You may be giving up substantial returns, year over year.鈥

You鈥檒l have to adjust your budget if you take a 401(k) loan with retirement savings.

If you don鈥檛 have another option for your debt but are wary of withdrawing from your retirement savings, you may consider a 401(k) loan.

  • Limitations:鈥疷p to 50% of vested account balance or $50,000 (whichever is less), in a 12-month period, unless the balance is less than $10,000 (then the borrowing limit is $10,000). Some plans don鈥檛 allow 401(k) loans. (The .)
  • Payback:鈥疻ithin five years, with payments made quarterly and with interest, which goes into the 401(k); if you leave your job, you must pay back the loan first.
  • Taxes and penalties: None if you meet the terms of the loan. If you don鈥檛 repay the loan, you鈥檒l be charged taxes and penalties.
  • Costs: You鈥檒l miss out on possible account growth during your loan repayment period.

Caution is key, Poorman says: A 401(k) loan is just that鈥攁 loan鈥攕o you鈥檒l be required to make monthly payments. Each month you have income that you can divvy up however you want鈥攔etirement, vacations, dinners out, and more. Your money is a tool for you to balance those tradeoffs and achieve your goals. 鈥淚t鈥檚 all about tradeoffs,鈥 Poorman says. 鈥(A 401(k) loan) will reduce your monthly income, so make sure it doesn鈥檛 put you in a worse situation for the immediate future,鈥 he says.

Fundamentals鈥攁 budget that aligns with your income and expenses鈥攃an help. And you may have debt repayment choices that help ease some of the pressure, Poorman says, including consolidation or negotiating with a creditor to figure out a reasonable repayment schedule.

鈥淵ou want to review every other option first,鈥 Poorman says. 鈥淲ould you have to work longer to make up those funds you withdrew? Would you end up in a similar situation a few years from now?鈥

What鈥檚 next?

Working on a budget and trying to figure out what debts to pay and how much to save? Log in to your 海角社区account to assess your retirement savings rate so you can see how much progress you鈥檙e making toward your goals.